Looney Tunes Wiki
Register
Advertisement
19

An example of the altered end title card featuring the new copyright notice superimposed on it

In the mid-1990s, Turner Entertainment, which had acquired the Associated Artists Productions (a.a.p.) library of pre-1948 Looney Tunes and Merrie Melodies cartoons in 1986, undertook a project to create new broadcast masters of the acquired cartoons as the existing 16mm prints in the library had become significantly degraded with age and repeated use over the decades. These prints also had the English audio remastered, and new foreign-language dubs created, as the original non-English audio of these cartoons was never preserved.

These prints had new end title cards that include a superimposed notice assigning copyright of these versions to Turner, thus replacing the original or Blue Ribbon rerelease end card. The notice reads: "DUBBED VERSION © 1994/1995 TURNER ENTERTAINMENT CO. MUSIC © 1994/1995 WARNER BROS. WARNER BROS. ALL LOGOS AND CHARACTERS ARE TRADEMARKS OF WARNER BROS.", referring to the the dubbed foreign-language soundtracks. Subsequently, these prints became known as "dubbed versions".

These "dubbed versions" are not necessarily representative of the original theatrical release versions of the shorts, as although the copyrights of the cartoons had been transferred to a.a.p. as part of the original sale, the library a.a.p. received contained only 35mm theatrical prints of the cartoons from which the previous 16mm prints had been made, not the original negatives, which were still in storage at Warner Bros. Many of the 35mm prints used were from later Blue Ribbon reissues with altered titles and closings.

In addition to the 1995-copyrighted prints, following Time Warner's acquisition of Turner in 1996, Warner Bros. created new prints of select post-1948 cartoons, including a similar copyright notice labeling them as "THIS VERSION" and either a 1997 or 1998 copyright date. These were originally used for home video releases outside the US.

Turner prints[]

In 1994 and 1995, as part of a Turner company-wide attempt to remaster and upgrade the quality of its entire classic animation archive library for television showings (specifically for the Turner-owned cable networks such as Cartoon Network, TBS, and TNT) and for future home media releases (e.g. The Golden Age of Looney Tunes: Volume 5 laserdisc), the company created new remastered transfers of the pre-1948 Looney Tunes cartoons. However, unlike the other cartoon shorts in Turner's library, Turner did not have access to the original master negatives of the pre-1948 Looney Tunes cartoons, therefore forcing them to use whatever limited film material they had in the Turner vaults.[1] As a result the Turner prints have rather varying degrees of image fidelity.[2][3][4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11][12][13]

These prints have the picture displayed in full wide and enlarged views, as opposed to the cropped "pan-and-scan" screen method used in the older transfers preceding them.[14] This is because when the dubbed versions were created, the 16mm duplicate film negatives were re-scanned, and film scanning technology of the 1990s had enabled more picture exposure than previous film scanning technology. "Yankee Doodle Daffy", "Daffy Duck in Hollywood", "Rhapsody in Rivets" and "Page Miss Glory" are among the "dubbed version" prints that benefited from this advantage.[15][16][17]

Ydd aap vs turner aspect ratio

A comparison image depicting how 1995 dubbed version prints (right) show more picture than their previous old a.a.p. prints (left), with Yankee Doodle Daffy (1943) being a good example of this

While Turner did edit the ending cards, they never omitted the cartoons' opening titles, unlike earlier broadcast prints which often omitted them. Most kept their original opening titles, but some of the cartoons had solid color borders around the opening titles, an artifact of the transfer process. Some cartoons which had lost their original opening titles in some of their a.a.p. prints previously broadcast on television had their original openings restored in the 1995 Turner prints.[18] For cartoons where the only available prints were Blue Ribbon re-issues, those opening titles remained.[19][20]

While most of these prints did not restore the original pre-Blue Ribbon titles, as the source of the transfers was from the old a.a.p. prints there are two exceptions, "Hiawatha's Rabbit Hunt" and "Hop, Look and Listen", which are the only cartoons whose Turner prints restored their original opening titles.[21] For "Daffy Duck & Egghead" and "The Night Watchman", recreations of their Blue Ribbon titles were created, as no opening titles were in the library.[22]

MM altered opening card by Turner

Recreated Merrie Melodies opening card seen on the Turner dubbed version prints of "Daffy Duck & Egghead" (1938) and "The Night Watchman" (1938)

Aside from the transfer color change and title alterations, the soundtracks in the 1995 dubbed versions have been partially remastered and restored, resulting in better sound quality than their previous a.a.p. prints, despite having some audible hiss and audio noise left intact [23] "Back Alley Oproar", "The Penguin Parade", "A Gruesome Twosome", "Hare Remover", "Lights Fantastic", "Birdy and the Beast" and "What's Cookin' Doc?" are among examples of 1995 dubbed version prints that benefited with better quality soundtracks in comparison to their older a.a.p. transfers preceding them. [24][25][26][27]

For the release of The Golden Age of Looney Tunes, Volume 5 LaserDisc in 1997, all cartoons but two are all Turner "dubbed" prints.[28][29]

While dubbed prints of the Censored Eleven and other cartoons from the a.a.p. library that had been removed from broadcast due to outdated stereotypes are said to exist, none of those prints were ever used for broadcast.

End title alterations[]

Generally, the end titles for the dubbed versions were selected based on the original release year and series of the cartoons following the below patterns, though there were exceptions.

  • 1931-1933 black-and-white Merrie Melodies by Harman-Ising - These cartoons kept their original ending card, but with the new copyright notice superimposed.
  • 1934-1935 color Merrie Melodies - If the cartoon was released between "Honeymoon Hotel" and "I Wanna Play House", but was not given a Blue Ribbon reissue, the Jester sign off from 1935's "My Green Fedora" was used but the original audio still plays and the new copyright notice is superimposed.
  • 1936-1944 color Merrie Melodies crediting Schlesinger - These cartoons mostly used the ending card sourced from 1938's "September in the Rain" (for NTSC prints) or "The Woods Are Full of Cuckoos" (for PAL prints) with the byline "Released by Warner Bros. Productions Corp." digitally removed and the new copyright notice superimposed; the final result is noticeably still-framed.
  • 1935-1948 color Merrie Melodies crediting Warner Bros. - These cartoons used an ending card sourced from 1948's "Bugs Bunny Rides Again" with the new copyright notice superimposed.
  • 1943-1944 color Looney Tunes - These cartoons had a generic drum ending card with red borders. For shorts produced by Leon Schlesinger, the byline "Released by Warner Bros. Pictures Inc." is digitally removed and the new copyright notice superimposed below.
  • 1946-1948 color Looney Tunes - These cartoons had an ending card sourced from 1948's "Haredevil Hare" with the new copyright notice superimposed.
  • Dubbed versions of the cartoons re-released in the 1952-53 season would have their "THE END" ending card replaced with the 1947-48 dubbed version ending card.

Foreign-language soundtrack changes[]

The original foreign-language soundtracks of the the pre-1948 shorts were not preserved by Warner Bros., so Turner had to recreate new foreign-language dubs for the cartoons using music cues taken from other Looney Tunes cartoons (particularly from the post-1948 shorts produced within the 1950s) and sound effects from Warner Bros.' sound archives. These dubbed soundtracks are what the copyright notice is specifically referring to in calling them the "dubbed versions", and why the copyright notice includes "MUSIC (C) 1995 WARNER BROS. (P) 1995 WARNER BROS.", giving credit for the music used to Warners. In almost all cases, the original ending music was kept, although sometimes, an earlier or later version of the closing theme is heard on the titles and some reissued Looney Tunes had their ending music changed to that of the Merrie Melodies series. In addition, some foreign language soundtracks have different music for versions released in Europe and the Americas, along with other differences in edits and source prints.

Controversy[]

Many animation fans and film preservationists have spoken out against the changes to the closing title cards as being inauthentic.[citation needed] (December 2021)

"The Old Grey Hare" in particular is cited as the shaking ending card gag is not present in NTSC version of the dubbed version, though the explosion was still heard. This is corrected in the PAL version of the same Turner remaster however, where the original "shaking" ending card gag is kept intact while the "DUBBED VERSION (C) 1995 TURNER ENTERTAINMENT, CO." end tag appears right after it.

1997–1998 Warner Bros. prints[]

This version 1997

THIS VERSION (C) 1997 WARNER BROS. copyright notice superimposed on the original ending card, as seen on 1997 dubbed version prints. Taken from "Catty Cornered" (1953)

Like the pre-1948 shorts, the original isolated music-and-effects track of nearly every cartoon produced between 1948 and 1949 and some cartoons produced between 1949 and 1953 were not preserved, so in 1997 and 1998 Warner Bros. made new masters of these cartoons with new foreign language dubs with a similar copyright notice added to the end titles.

The new music-and-effects-only tracks were reconstructed using the same methods as the 1995 Turner prints of pre-1948 cartoons. Unlike the 1995 Turner dubbed versions, most of these masters were derived from the original negatives, and most feature restored original titles and the original ending Color Rings.

Though some of the 1997 titles use the "DUBBED VERSION" wording for the new copyright notice, many of these prints used "THIS VERSION" instead. Unlike the Turner prints, versions of these masters exist both with and without the copyright notice.

These prints made their home video debut on the Bugs and Friends Japanese laserdisc set and 1998 international VHS releases with the new copyright notice. Shortly after some also appeared on both the Looney Tunes Presents and Looney Tunes: The Collectors Edition VHS releases without the copyright notice at the end, as these were English-language releases and did not need the new dubbed-language audio. Several of these were used on the Looney Tunes Golden Collection series of DVDs, also without the notice.

1997–98 prints on television[]

In the late-1990s and early-2000s, the 1997–1998 masters were used for television distribution, beginning with various Cartoon Network/Boomerang feeds worldwide, replacing previous unrestored prints of post-1948 shorts, even though even as recent as 2011 some of these post-1948 shorts were still shown as the unrestored versions on various Cartoon Network/Boomerang feeds in may parts of the world. In short, television broadcast availability of these 1997–1998 prints tend to vary greatly depending on the country.

VHS releases containing the 1997–1998 prints[]

1997-98 prints on later home video releases[]

VHS[]

  • "Mad as a Mars Hare" (Marvin the Martian & K-9: 50 Years on Earth!/Marvin the Martian: Space Tunes (reissued version))
  • "Duck Dodgers and the Return of the 24½th Century" (Marvin the Martian & K-9: 50 Years on Earth!/Marvin the Martian: Space Tunes (reissued version))
  • "Dog Pounded" (Tweety: Home Tweet Home)
  • "The Jet Cage" (Tweety: Home Tweet Home)
  • "Bad Ol' Putty Tat" (Tweety: Home Tweet Home)
  • "Tweety's S.O.S." (Tweety: Home Tweet Home)
  • "A Street Cat Named Sylvester" (Tweety: Home Tweet Home, only on PAL release)
  • "Muzzle Tough" (Tweety: Tweet and Lovely, only on PAL release)
  • "Tweety's Circus" (Tweety: Tweet and Lovely)
  • "Greedy for Tweety" (Tweety: Tweet and Lovely)
  • "Catty Cornered" (Tweety: Tweet and Lovely)
  • "Bully for Bugs" (Bugs Bunny: Big Top Bunny, only on PAL release)
  • "Big Top Bunny" (Bugs Bunny: Big Top Bunny)
  • "Water, Water Every Hare" (Bugs Bunny: Big Top Bunny)
  • "Rabbit Rampage" (Bugs Bunny: Big Top Bunny)
  • "The Abominable Snow Rabbit" (Bugs Bunny: Big Top Bunny)
  • "Rabbit's Kin" (Bugs Bunny: Big Top Bunny)
  • "Foxy by Proxy" (Bugs Bunny: Big Top Bunny)
  • "My Bunny Lies over the Sea" (Bugs Bunny: Big Top Bunny)
  • "Baton Bunny" (Bugs Bunny: Big Top Bunny)
  • "Dough for the Do-Do" (Taz's Jungle Jams)
  • "Rabbit Seasoning" (LTCE: Vol 1: All-Stars)
  • "Tweety's S.O.S." (LTCE: Vol 1: All-Stars)
  • "The Foghorn Leghorn" (LTCE: Vol 1: All-Stars)
  • "Scaredy Cat" (LTCE: Vol 2: Running Amuck)
  • "Feed the Kitty" (LTCE: Vol 2: Running Amuck)
  • "Boyhood Daze" (LTCE: Vol 2: Running Amuck)
  • "My Bunny Lies over the Sea" (LTCE: Vol 2: Running Amuck)
  • "Awful Orphan" (LTCE: Vol 3: The Vocal Genius)
  • "The Stupor Salesman" (LTCE: Vol 3: The Vocal Genius)
  • "A Fractured Leghorn" (LTCE: Vol 3: The Vocal Genius)
  • "Golden Yeggs" (LTCE: Vol 3: The Vocal Genius)
  • "Rabbit Fire" (LTCE: Vol 3: The Vocal Genius)
  • "Lovelorn Leghorn" (LTCE: Vol 4: Daffy Doodles)
  • "Big Top Bunny" (LTCE: Vol 4: Daffy Doodles)
  • "Baton Bunny" (LTCE: Vol 5: Musical Masterpieces)
  • "Mouse Mazurka" (LTCE: Vol 5: Musical Masterpieces)
  • "Rabbit's Kin" (LTCE: Vol 6: Supporting Players)
  • "I Gopher You" (LTCE: Vol 6: Supporting Players)
  • "Don't Give Up The Sheep" (LTCE: Vol 6: Supporting Players)
  • "Water, Water Every Hare" (LTCE: Vol 6: Supporting Players)
  • "High Diving Hare" (LTCE: Vol 9: A Looney Life)
  • "Kit For Cat" (LTCE: Vol 9: A Looney Life)
  • "Bunker Hill Bunny" (LTCE: Vol 9: A Looney Life)
  • "A Mouse Divided" (LTCE: Vol 9: A Looney Life)
  • "Feline Frame-Up" (LTCE: Vol 10: Canine Corps)
  • "Muzzle Tough" (LTCE: Vol 10: Canine Corps)
  • "Mad as a Mars Hare" (LTCE: Vol 11: Wabbit Tales)
  • "Dog Pounded" (LTCE: Vol 14: Cartoon Superstars)
  • "The Million Hare" (LTCE: Vol 14: Cartoon Superstars)

DVD/Blu-Ray[]

Some of these 1997-98 prints show up on official Warner Home Video DVDs and Blu-Rays, but do not have the dubbed notice at the end.

  • "The Foghorn Leghorn" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Scaredy Cat" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Ballot Box Bunny" (LTSS: WW, only on PAL release)
  • "Rabbit's Kin" (LTSS: WW, only on PAL release)
  • "Bad Ol' Putty Tat" (LTSS: FF, only on PAL release)
  • "Ant Pasted" (LTSS: HH, with the cue mark)
  • "The Wearing of the Grin" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "The Ducksters" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Deduce, You Say" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Dough for the Do-Do" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "A Broken Leghorn" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Canned Feud" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Bunker Hill Bunny" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Baton Bunny" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Water, Water Every Hare" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Big House Bunny" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Rabbit Seasoning" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Lumber Jerks" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Feed the Kitty" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "The Hypo-Chondri Cat" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Don't Give Up the Sheep" (LTGC: Vol 1)
  • "Boyhood Daze" (LTGC: Vol 6)
  • "Mouse Mazurka" (LTMC, only in the United States)
  • "Lovelorn Leghorn" (I'll See You In My Dreams)
  • "I Gopher You" (His Majesty O'Keef)
  • "From A to Z-Z-Z-Z" (By the Light of the Silvery Moon)
  • "Hyde and Hare" (Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde)
  • "Beep Prepared" (Splendor in the Grass)
  • "From Hare to Eternity" (LTPC: Vol 1 - with 1998 Dubbed Version notice)
  • "Mad as a Mars Hare" (Bugs Bunny's Lunar Tunes/Marvin the Martian: Space Tunes Double Feature)
  • "Duck Dodgers and the Return of the 24½th Century" (Bugs Bunny's Lunar Tunes/Marvin the Martian: Space Tunes Double Feature/Daffy Duck's Quackbusters)

References[]

  1. https://web.archive.org/web/20011201200256/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update1.html.
  2. https://web.archive.org/web/20011109090448/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update8.html
  3. https://web.archive.org/web/20011217165933/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update13.html
  4. https://web.archive.org/web/20011217165122/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update12.html
  5. https://web.archive.org/web/20010629011002/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update7.html
  6. https://web.archive.org/web/20011109074815/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update5.html
  7. https://web.archive.org/web/20010822163006/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update3.html
  8. https://web.archive.org/web/20011109052424/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update15.html
  9. https://web.archive.org/web/20011217164924/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update11.html
  10. https://web.archive.org/web/20011109055301/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update16.html
  11. https://web.archive.org/web/20011217172316/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update17.html
  12. https://web.archive.org/web/20011217172920/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update18.html
  13. https://web.archive.org/web/20011217173850/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update19.html
  14. https://web.archive.org/web/20011109080003/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update6.html
  15. https://web.archive.org/web/20011109074815/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update5.html.
  16. https://web.archive.org/web/20011109080003/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update6.html
  17. https://web.archive.org/web/20010629011002/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update7.html
  18. https://web.archive.org/web/20011217163132/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update1.html
  19. archive.org
  20. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ZHmTgKJYcnOt4sY2R_ok6ep-8rJDSOrm/view
  21. https://web.archive.org/web/20011217163132/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update1.html
  22. https://web.archive.org/web/20010629011002/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update7.html
  23. https://web.archive.org/web/20011109064612/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update2.html
  24. https://web.archive.org/web/20011109080003/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update6.html
  25. https://web.archive.org/web/20010629011002/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update7.html
  26. https://web.archive.org/web/20011109090448/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update8.html
  27. https://web.archive.org/web/20011109055301/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update16.html
  28. https://web.archive.org/web/20011217163132/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update1.html
  29. https://web.archive.org/web/20011109074815/http://www.megalink.net/~cooke/looney/update5.html
Advertisement